Agenda and minutes

Stronger City Economy Scrutiny Panel - Tuesday, 28th July, 2015 6.00 pm

Venue: Committee Room 3 - 3rd Floor - Civic Centre. View directions

Contact: Deb Breedon  01902 551250 or Email:

No. Item




Apologies were submitted on behalf of Cllrs Payal Bedi, Daniel Warren and Welcome Koussoukama.


Work Programme




That the work programme be discussed in conjunction with the final item on the agenda relating to corporate priorities


Declarations of Interest


There were no declarations of interest


Nominations for Vice-Chair


Cllr Jonathan Yardley was nominated by the Chair and duly seconded by Cllr Paul Singh to be Vice-Chair of the Stronger City Economy Scrutiny Panel for municipal year 2015-16.


That Cllr Jonathan Yardley be elected Vice-Chair of the Stronger City Economy Scrutiny Panel for municipal year 2015-16



Chairs welcome

[Cllr Jacqueline Sweetman, Chair Stronger City Economy Scrutiny Panel]


The Chair welcomed councillors and officers to the Stronger City Economy scrutiny panel.  She gave special thanks to Cllr John Rowley as former Chair of the Enterprise and Business scrutiny panel.   

The Chair advised the panel that a discussion would take place as the last item to agree what the panel should concentrate on this municipal year, she suggested the panel need to consider what is on the money, including investment, jobs and wealth to the City.


Overview of external funding pdf icon PDF 110 KB

[To provide background information and a presentation to give an overview of external funding available and secured in order to deliver our corporate priorities with a focus on City economy activity.]


Heather Clark, Service Development Manager provided a report to give background and presentation to give the panel and an overview on external funding. 

The presentation outlined:

·         Attracting external funding

·         Achievements: developing a vibrant city; stronger city economy; access to finance

·         Approach : Support to access funding; influencing funders; hide the wiring for businesses to access finance to enable growth

·         Opportunity: Supporting business, encouraging enterprise and attracting investment; people developing the skills and employability; pipeline development


Cllr Phil Bateman said it is useful to see the bids pipeline development in a simple diagram. The Chair thanked officers for the presentation and invited questions from the panel:


Cllr Martin Waite referred to the recent Cabinet external funding update report and referred to the broader landscape, funding bids from UK and Europe and asked about risks of funding that has been awarded but not yet received by Wolverhampton, potentially being snatched away from the City.  Keren Jones, Service Director advised that the European funds are tied in through a process agreed at European level, she advised it is unlikely that any retraction of funding would happen at this stage of the process; therefore planning for the projects arising out of the funding will continue and will be followed through to delivery.  She clarified that there is a good pipeline of projects in terms of schemes that we will be able to deliver.


She advised that the Council is watching the local growth fund closely at the moment in terms of the Universal Spending Review and indicated that there are very challenging circumstances ahead, it is likely that Further Education (FE) will be significantly affected. Cllr John Reynolds, Cabinet Member for City Economy advised that there will be mid-year cuts to Adult Education Services (AES) funding from September 2015.


In response to questions relating to green economies such as solar power, the Service Director advised that Cabinet (Resources) Panel agreed a report in April 2015 endorsing the proposal to adopt the EU framework for Smart City and agreement to the approach to driving forward the Smart City agenda, which includes the green economy. She advised that there were three really strong projects underway that had been submitted in the first round.


Cllr Martin Waite welcomed that all the bids are moving forward in a five year programme prior to the referendum on European. The Service Development Manager advised that the normal roll out of funding is contract and three years to spend.  She advised that we need to ensure as much funding as possible in this round of bids committed before January 2016. She clarified that the contracts should be complete and projects ready to deliver in January 2016.


Cllr Phil Bateman indicated that one really important element of strong economies is private business and the private sector.  He indicated that he had requested information about foreign owned businesses in Wednesfield North and South. He commented that much of the business world grows and invests without public sector intervention, and asked how we are  ...  view the full minutes text for item 6.


Corporate Priorities relating to the Stronger City Economy Scrutiny Panel remit pdf icon PDF 205 KB

[The two objectives for the Place Directorate this fall within this panel remit are:

·         Supporting Business, Encouraging Enterprise and Investment

·         Improving our critical Skills and Employability Approach


The papers provides information about performance indicators and monitoring performance]


Keren Jones, Service Director outlined the corporate priorities for place relating to Stronger Economy.  Cllr Phil Bateman referred to comments made earlier in the meeting relating to the 17 foreign investors that have moved in to the Wednesfield area creating jobs and increasing economic viability of the area. He suggested that 12% of industry in Wednesfield is advanced manufacturing which is a good example for Wolverhampton. He requested that when setting policies this should be taken into account and that the Council should not focus exclusively on three priority areas.

The Service Director assured the Panel that the corporate priorities take account of the issues raised by Cllr Phil Bateman, she advised that the Council will be acting in a brokerage role to work with specialist sector organisations in a sectorial base, as well as a geographical base. She advised that there is more work to do on the infrastructure however work around joint venture funding is on-going and talks with Wiggle, UTC and foreign owned companies are on-going.


The Service Development Manager informed the panel about installation of Cabinets for superfast broadband in Wednesfield to support businesses and to attract others to the area. Cllr Paul Singh and Harman Banger welcomed the developments in Wednesfield, Cllr Harman Banger commented that the size of the business and the impact it has on the City is important when attracting inward investment. Panel discussed the need to attract small and medium enterprises (SMEs) to the City as well as larger organisations.


Cllr Harman Banger suggested that there is a need for a complete package to promote inward investment opportunities. He asked how Wolverhampton compared with other Councils, in particular how Wolverhampton is reflected on the internet - sites, lifestyle, and the complete package.


The Chair highlighted the draft work programme that had been tabled for information; she indicated that several themed sessions would pick up the issues highlighted in discussion during the meeting the including inward investment and the visitor economy. 

The Service Director advised panel that the additional session on 24 September 2015 would be timely to provide information about ‘Making it Happen’ and how we are selling Wolverhampton abroad; improvement to the website and the launch of Business Week 2015.  Further information was shared with the panel in terms of the inward investment session and that a dedicated officer has been recruited to focus on city investment and the gap in terms of European funding available to encourage investment of SMEs. 


In response to further questions the Service Director confirmed that the Council’s corporate communications teams are all involved in the marketing of the city.


Cllr Martin Waite asked whether the Council has enough resources to support existing businesses to upscale and whether the marketing of Wolverhampton is outward facing to external companies. The Service Director advised that a part of the focus for the City Economy Service is the conference programme to bring everything together.  Three conferences based on themes of: Working well; Business Week;  ...  view the full minutes text for item 7.